Skip to main content

Judge's Notebook: Action Fizzling

Many of you have heard that an action can "fizzle," but what is that because it's not in the rulebook.

Fizzle: A Definition

Since Vampire: The Eternal Struggle and Magic: The Gathering were siblings, the DCI governed the rulings and competitive play for both games.  Fizzle started off as a term in Magic for a spell that resolved without effect, and was brought into VTES via rulings.

Fizzle does not appear in the rulebook, but the slang, semi-official term is in the rulings.  The earliest reference to it is in RTR-19960221 actually contains no definition of the term.  However, it's not until RTR-20010711 that we have a definition in VTES: the action "fizzles" (resolves with no effect).

How Did We Get Here?

If an action does not meet all requirements at resolution, the action will fizzle.

  • The acting vampire no longer has enough blood to pay for the action (Govern the Unaligned with 0 blood)
    • Note that the acting vampire must have been able to pay for the action to declare it.  This usually means the acting vampire spent too much blood on action modifiers to resolve the action without fizzling.
  • The target of the action is missing (Entrancement on a War Ghoul that burns itself to burn a location)
  • The target is no longer in the correct state
    • Target is unlocked when it needs to be locked (target plays Deep Ecology when rushed with Nose of the Hound)
    • Target is locked when it needs to be unlocked (target of Mind Numb plays Babble to unlock another minion)
    • Target is no longer in torpor (target of a diablerie attempt moves to the ready region via Warsaw Station)
  • The card providing the action is
    • No longer in play (Camera Phone burned in combat and the acting vampire plays Momentary Delay)
    • No longer usable by the acting minion (Talbot's rush stymied by Peacemaker B)

There are certainly many more examples that we can come up with, but I tried to provide the most general categories for action fizzling with examples.

The Outcome

Fizzled actions have no effect, but are successfully resolved.  This means:

  • The action cost is paid (or as much of it as can be paid is paid)
  • The action produces no effect
  • The action has reached resolution and is now bound by "no repeat actions," if applicable
  • Action modifiers and reactions that are "only usable after action resolution" are playable, if their conditions can be met
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The V5-Only Format

The idea of a V5-only format has been floated by BCP for some time.  Ideally, this is a way to level the playing field for newer players.  Some folks have, of course, lost their collective minds about the idea.  More ways to play VTES and easier formats to bring in new players sounds exactly like what the doctor ordered to me. Steve has been running several online tournaments this year, a subset of which were in the V5-only format.  I wasn't able to make his earlier V5-only events, but was able to make this last one.  Here are my thoughts about it.  Is V5-only worthwhile?  Let's find out. What I Played I had a few ideas that I wanted to experiment with: Queen Anne + obf/pre Princes, using Banishment (she's one of the oldest vampires available); Malk voters; Banu voters; and Nos Barons.  I'm glad that I didn't pick either of the first two as both of those showed up in the event.  I've previously won with a...
2 comments
Read more

Contesting Changes That Didn't Happen

It's been more than 18-months since Black Chantry Productions attempted to test a rule change for vampire contesting.  Given that my NDA has expired regarding that test and we have a new format in open playtest, I wondered if it was time to talk about resurrecting the potential change. Proposed Change This text is from the rules test and not my invention.  The highlight section is the proposed change: At any time during this phase, if a vampire has at least as many blood counters as their capacity, you can move that vampire face up to the ready region, unlocked. The counters are kept on them to represent their blood.  Counters in excess of his capacity drain off immediately as usual. If the vampire grants additional transfers, those cannot be used on this turn because transfers are gained at the start of the influence phase. If the vampire would contest, you may choose to remove it from the game instead of moving it to the ready region and distribute the pool on it among ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Let's Build: V5 Toreador with Fortitude

It's our great pleasure to provide the final Toreador spoiler for the new Fifth Edition boxed set.  Without further ado, let's meet Catalina Vega with artwork by Mitch Mueller.
Post a Comment
Read more